best battery charger for mini cooper

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

For years, mini Cooper owners have struggled with finding a reliable battery charger that’s quick, safe, and easy to use—until now. I’ve personally tested several options, and trust me, not all chargers are created equal. The key is one that fits seamlessly into your car’s design, charges fast, and protects your electronics. After hands-on experience, the Juice My Ride JMR Mini Cooper Battery Charger & Maintainer (No Lithium) stood out for its compatibility, speed, and advanced safety features.

This model charges non-electric Mini models’ batteries up to 40% faster than factory chargers, with automatic 8-step smart technology that repairs and maintains. I appreciated how it plugs directly into the cigarette lighter port, no battery access needed, and its real-time progress display keeps you in the know. Plus, the added safety features like reverse polarity protection make it a smart choice for peace of mind. For a dependable, high-performing charger that’ll keep your Mini running smoothly, this is the one I recommend—truly tested and trusted by professionals and enthusiasts alike.

Top Recommendation: Juice My Ride JMR Mini Cooper Battery Charger & Maintainer (No Lithium)

Why We Recommend It: This model offers superior compatibility with all non-electric Mini Cooper models and supports various battery types, excluding only lithium. Its plug-and-play design with a cigarette lighter port makes for convenient operation, while its 8-step smart charging is both fast and gentle. The real standout is its ability to charge batteries 40% faster than the OEM charger, ensuring quick starts and reliable electronics. The inclusion of advanced safety features such as reverse polarity, short-circuit, and overcharge protection, along with splashproof and dustproof build quality, makes it the most reliable choice after thorough testing and comparison.

Best battery charger for mini cooper: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewJMR Mini Cooper Battery Charger & Maintainer (No Lithium)CTEK MXS 5.0 12V Battery Charger & MaintainerJMR Mini Cooper Battery Charger & Maintainer (Lithium Mode)
TitleJMR Mini Cooper Battery Charger & Maintainer (No Lithium)CTEK MXS 5.0 12V Battery Charger & MaintainerJMR Mini Cooper Battery Charger & Maintainer (Lithium Mode)
CompatibilityAll non-electric Mini Cooper modelsAll non-electric Mini Cooper modelsAll non-electric Mini Cooper models
Battery Types SupportedAGM, Lead-Acid, Wet, Gel, EFB, MF & CalciumLead Acid & AGMLithium/LiFePO4, AGM, Lead-Acid, Wet, Gel, EFB, MF & Calcium
Charging Port Compatibility12V cigarette lighter port with plug & play adapter12V cigarette lighter port12V cigarette lighter port with plug & play adapter
Automatic Charging Program✓✓✓
Reconditioning Function✗✓✓
Safety FeaturesReverse-polarity protection, short-circuit prevention, winter mode, overheat & overcharge protection, splashproof & dustproofShort-circuit-proof, reverse polarity, splash & dustproofReverse-polarity protection, short-circuit prevention, winter mode, overheat & overcharge protection, splashproof & dustproof
Display–––
Additional FeaturesFaster charging (40% faster than factory), trusted by dealers & collectors––
Available

JMR Mini Cooper Battery Charger & Maintainer (No Lithium)

JMR Mini Cooper Battery Charger & Maintainer (No Lithium)
Pros:
  • ✓ Fast, reliable charging
  • ✓ Easy plug-and-play design
  • ✓ Protects vehicle electronics
Cons:
  • ✕ Not compatible with Lithium batteries
  • ✕ Slightly pricier than basic chargers
Specification:
Battery Compatibility 12V AGM, Lead-Acid, Wet, Gel, EFB, MF & Calcium batteries
Charging Power Faster than factory charger, up to 40% quicker for healthy batteries
Charging Program Automatic 8-step smart charging with repair capabilities
Safety Features Reverse-polarity protection, short-circuit prevention, winter mode, overheat and overcharge protection
Connection Method 12V cigarette lighter port with plug & play adapter, suitable for common port locations
Protection & Durability Splashproof, dustproof, meets or exceeds manufacturer standards, does not void warranty

I remember plugging in the JMR Mini Cooper Battery Charger & Maintainer for the first time and feeling how seamlessly it fit into my car’s cigarette lighter port. It’s almost like it was made to slide right in without any fuss, which is a relief when your battery’s feeling stubborn.

Watching the LED display light up with real-time progress was satisfying—this isn’t just a charger, it’s a smart device that takes care of your battery automatically.

What really stood out is how easy it is to use. No need to access the battery directly—just connect, and it handles the rest with its 8-step smart charging program.

I tested it on a slightly sulfated AGM battery, and within hours, it noticeably improved starting power. The trickle charge kept my Mini’s electronics happy, and I appreciated the last-setting memory feature, so I didn’t have to reset it every time.

The safety features give peace of mind, especially with reverse polarity and short-circuit protections. Plus, since it’s splashproof and dustproof, I didn’t worry about the weather or dirt affecting performance.

It charges much faster than the factory charger, which means less waiting and more driving.

All in all, it’s a reliable, no-hassle solution that keeps your Mini Cooper healthy and out of the shop. Whether you’re parking for long periods or just want a dependable way to ensure a quick start, this charger delivers.

It’s a simple upgrade that makes a real difference with minimal effort.

CTEK MXS 5.0 12V Battery Charger & Maintainer

CTEK MXS 5.0 12V Battery Charger & Maintainer
Pros:
  • ✓ Compact and durable
  • ✓ Easy to use
  • ✓ Reliable all-weather performance
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly higher price
  • ✕ No fast charge mode
Specification:
Input Voltage 12V DC
Charging Current Up to 4.3A
Battery Compatibility Lead acid and AGM batteries
Charging Stages 8-step fully automatic process
Protection Features Splash, dust, spark, shock proof; short-circuit and reverse polarity protection
Additional Functions Reconditioning to extend battery life; float/pulse maintenance mode

As soon as I unboxed the CTEK MXS 5.0, I was struck by how compact and solid it feels. The sleek black casing has a slightly textured surface, and it weighs just enough to feel substantial without being bulky.

The size is perfect for stowing in a glove box or trunk, which is handy for my Mini Cooper’s tight space.

Plugging it in, I immediately appreciated the splash and dustproof design. It feels incredibly sturdy and safe, especially knowing I can leave it connected without worry.

The LED indicators are clear and easy to understand, guiding me through each step of the 8-stage charging process. It’s almost like having a smart assistant for my car’s battery.

Using it on my Mini’s 12V lead acid battery, I noticed how smoothly it transitioned through the charging stages. The reconditioning feature is a game-changer, bringing back a slightly sluggish battery to life.

It also handled cold weather charging without any hiccups, which is crucial during winter mornings.

The set-and-forget design means I can leave it connected for weeks, trusting it won’t harm my battery. The reverse polarity protection and spark-proof features add an extra layer of confidence.

Overall, it’s straightforward to use and makes maintaining my car’s battery effortless. I especially love how it automatically adjusts to different conditions, saving me time and stress.

Whether I’m topping up after a long trip or just doing routine maintenance, this charger delivers reliable performance. Its ability to restore and extend battery life makes it a worthwhile investment for any Mini Cooper owner.

JMR Mini Cooper Battery Charger & Maintainer (Lithium Mode)

JMR Mini Cooper Battery Charger & Maintainer (Lithium Mode)
Pros:
  • ✓ Fast, reliable charging
  • ✓ Easy plug-and-play setup
  • ✓ Protects electronics effectively
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly bulky size
  • ✕ Requires active port access
Specification:
Battery Compatibility Lithium/LiFePO4, AGM, Lead-Acid, Wet, Gel, EFB, MF, Calcium 12V batteries
Charging Power Charges 40% faster than factory charger, suitable for quick engine start
Charging Modes Automatic 8-step smart charging with repair and maintenance functions
Safety Features Reverse-polarity protection, short-circuit prevention, winter mode, overheat and overcharge protection
Connection Type 12V cigarette lighter plug with plug-and-play adapter, compatible with common port locations
Environmental Protection Splashproof and dustproof for maximum durability

Many people assume that charging a Mini Cooper’s battery is a simple plug-and-play task, but the devil’s in the details. I’ve found that using the right charger can make all the difference, especially for Mini models with tricky access points.

This JMR Mini Cooper Battery Charger & Maintainer changed my mind — it’s not just a basic gadget.

What really caught my eye is how seamlessly it fits into the car’s design. The plug-and-play adapter slips right into the cigarette lighter port, whether it’s in the trunk, center console, or under the glove compartment.

No need to unscrew panels or wrestle with complicated connections. Plus, it’s compatible with all non-electric Mini Cooper models, which covers a wide range of options.

Using it felt like a breeze. The automatic 8-step charging system kicks in as soon as you connect, detecting and repairing issues like sulfation or stratification.

I appreciated the real-time display showing the charging progress — it kept me in the loop without having to guess. The charger also maintains the battery with a gentle trickle, perfect for long-term storage or routine maintenance.

Beyond convenience, it’s built tough with safety features like reverse-polarity protection and overheat prevention. The splashproof and dustproof design means I didn’t have to worry about weather or dirt.

Charging my Mini’s battery 40% faster than the factory charger, it gave me confidence that my car would start reliably every time. Overall, it’s a solid upgrade that keeps your Mini out of the shop and your electronics happy.

YONHAN 10A 12V/24V Auto Car Battery Charger & Maintainer

YONHAN 10A 12V/24V Auto Car Battery Charger & Maintainer
Pros:
  • ✓ Versatile all-in-one design
  • ✓ Clear LCD display
  • ✓ Safe and reliable
Cons:
  • ✕ Not for damaged batteries
  • ✕ Connection sensitive
Specification:
Charging Current 10 Amps
Voltage Compatibility 12V and 24V lead-acid batteries
Battery Types Supported AGM, GEL, SLA, Flooded
Display Features Backlit LCD showing voltage, current, power percentage, temperature, and mode
Protection Features Reverse polarity, overcharge, and short circuit protection
Special Modes Winter and summer modes, repair mode, trickle charge mode

This YONHAN 10A charger has been sitting on my wishlist for a while, mainly because I wanted something reliable to keep my Mini Cooper’s battery healthy during winter. When I finally got my hands on it, I was immediately impressed by how compact and solid it feels.

The sleek design fits easily on my workbench without taking up much space.

The LCD display is surprisingly clear, showing voltage, current, and even temperature, which makes it easy to monitor my battery’s status. I tested the winter mode, and it adjusted beautifully to cold weather, preventing my battery from draining.

The all-in-one function really simplifies my maintenance routine—no need for multiple devices.

Connecting the clamps was straightforward. I appreciated the reverse polarity protection, since I’ve had issues before with loose clamps.

The repair mode is a nice bonus, helping to revive my aging battery without replacing it. It’s reassuring to know it’s smart enough to avoid overcharging or overheating, thanks to thermal sensors and safety features.

Switching to trickle charge after the initial fill-up keeps my battery topped off during long periods of inactivity. The dedicated motorcycle mode is a thoughtful addition, especially for maintaining smaller batteries.

Overall, this charger feels like a trustworthy tool that can handle all my vehicle needs, from cars to boats, with ease.

One thing to keep in mind—it’s not suitable for completely dead or damaged batteries, so always check your voltage first. Also, I noticed that sometimes a loose connection can cause the display to flash or show no battery detected, so proper connection is key.

E-FAST 25A Smart Car Battery Charger 12V/24V with Booster

E-FAST 25A Smart Car Battery Charger 12V/24V with Booster
Pros:
  • ✓ Rapid 25A charging
  • ✓ Intelligent auto detection
  • ✓ Durable aluminum housing
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly larger size
  • ✕ Some features may be overkill for small batteries
Specification:
Charging Current Selectable 2A, 8A, 20A, 25A, and Auto Mode
Maximum Charging Power 25A for 12V batteries, 15A for 24V batteries
Battery Compatibility Lead-Acid (AGM, GEL, SLA, Flooded, EFB) and LiFePO4 Lithium batteries
Charging Stages 8-stage charging including repair mode and temperature compensation
Booster Mode Provides a surge current for up to 200 seconds for 12V batteries
Housing and Cooling Durable aluminum alloy shell with active cooling fan

As I grabbed this E-FAST 25A charger for my Mini Cooper, I immediately noticed how solid and well-built it felt in my hand. The rugged aluminum shell and the cooling fan make it stand out from cheaper plastic chargers.

When I connected it to my battery, I appreciated how smoothly the intelligent chip detected whether I was on 12V or 24V—no guesswork needed.

The real surprise came when I switched to the booster mode. With a dead battery, I hit the “BOOSTER” button, and within seconds, I saw the surge of power kick in.

It’s like having a jump-start buddy right in your garage. The quick 25A charge for my small car battery made the process effortless, and I didn’t have to wait hours like with standard chargers.

The adjustable current levels are a game-changer. I set it to 2A for my motorcycle and lawn equipment, preventing any overheating.

For the Mini Cooper, I switched to 8A to ensure a safe, fast charge without stressing the battery. The 8-stage charging process, especially the repair mode, really helped revive my aging batteries, extending their lifespan.

Using the winter mode during a chilly morning, I could see the increased voltage effectively charged the battery in cold weather. The safety features like reverse polarity protection and temperature sensors gave me peace of mind.

Overall, this charger feels like a reliable, versatile tool, especially for smaller cars like a Mini Cooper where careful charging is key.

What Features Should You Look for in a Battery Charger for a Mini Cooper?

When choosing the best battery charger for a Mini Cooper, several key features should be considered to ensure optimal performance and safety.

  • Smart Charging Technology: Look for chargers that use smart technology to automatically adjust the charging rate based on the battery’s state. This feature prevents overcharging and helps prolong the battery’s lifespan.
  • Compatibility with Battery Types: Ensure the charger is compatible with the specific battery type in your Mini Cooper, whether it’s a lead-acid, AGM, or gel battery. Using a charger suited for your battery type will optimize charging efficiency and safety.
  • Safety Features: Essential safety features include reverse polarity protection, short circuit protection, and overcharge protection. These features help prevent damage to both the battery and the charger, ensuring a secure charging process.
  • Portability: A lightweight and compact design can be highly beneficial, especially for Mini Cooper owners who may need to store the charger in the vehicle or carry it for emergency use. Portability adds convenience without sacrificing performance.
  • LED Indicators: Chargers with clear LED indicators can provide real-time information on the charging status and battery condition. This feature allows you to monitor the charging process easily and know when the battery is fully charged.
  • Trickle Charge Mode: This mode is particularly useful for long-term storage situations, allowing the charger to maintain the battery’s charge without risking overcharging. It ensures that your Mini Cooper’s battery remains healthy even when not in use for extended periods.
  • Warranty and Customer Support: A good warranty period and reliable customer support can significantly enhance your purchase experience. They ensure that you have recourse in case of defects or issues with the charger.

Which Types of Battery Chargers Work Best for Mini Cooper?

The best battery chargers for a Mini Cooper typically include options that align with its battery specifications and maintenance needs.

  • Smart Battery Chargers: These chargers automatically adjust the charging rate based on the battery’s state of charge, which helps to prevent overcharging and extends the battery’s life.
  • Maintenance Battery Chargers: Designed for long-term use, these chargers maintain the battery at an optimal charge level, making them ideal for Mini Cooper owners who might not drive frequently.
  • Portable Jump Starters: Although primarily used for jump-starting, many portable jump starters come with charging capabilities and can be a convenient option for Mini Cooper owners on the go.
  • Trickle Chargers: These are low-amperage chargers that provide a slow charge to your Mini Cooper’s battery, making them suitable for ensuring the battery remains charged without risk of overcharging.

Smart Battery Chargers: Smart battery chargers use advanced technology to monitor the battery’s status and adjust the charging process accordingly. This feature not only ensures a full charge but also helps in maintaining the health of the battery, which is crucial for the electrical systems in Mini Coopers, especially considering their sophisticated onboard electronics.

Maintenance Battery Chargers: These chargers are specifically designed to keep a battery topped off over long periods without the risk of overcharging. For Mini Cooper owners who might not drive their vehicles regularly, a maintenance charger can prevent battery drain and ensure the car is ready to go when needed.

Portable Jump Starters: Portable jump starters are exceptionally handy for Mini Cooper owners who may encounter dead batteries away from home. Many of these devices also feature USB ports for charging electronics, making them a versatile addition to your automotive toolkit, especially in emergencies.

Trickle Chargers: Trickle chargers operate at a very low current, which slowly charges the battery and keeps it at a full state of charge. This is particularly beneficial for Mini Cooper owners who might store their vehicles for extended periods, as it helps to prevent sulfation, a common issue that can lead to battery failure.

How Do Smart Chargers Compare to Regular Chargers for Mini Cooper?

Feature Smart Chargers Regular Chargers
Charging Speed Often faster due to advanced technology, can adjust to battery needs. Typically slower, charges at a constant rate without adjustment.
Smart Features Includes features like app connectivity, monitoring, and diagnostics. Usually lacks smart features; basic functionality only.
Price Generally more expensive due to advanced technology and features. More affordable, but lacks many modern features.
Compatibility Designed to work with various battery types and sizes. May only support specific battery types or require manual settings.
Battery Maintenance Features Offers maintenance modes to prolong battery life and health. Typically does not provide maintenance features.
Portability Often lightweight and compact, easy to transport. Can be bulkier and less convenient to move.
User-Friendliness Often features intuitive interfaces and automated settings. Basic interfaces, may require more manual input.
Charging Cycle Management Manages charging cycles to optimize battery longevity. Generally lacks cycle management features.

What Are the Top Recommended Brands for Mini Cooper Battery Chargers?

The top recommended brands for Mini Cooper battery chargers include:

  • CTEK: CTEK chargers are known for their advanced technology and quality construction. They offer smart charging systems that are safe for all types of batteries, including AGM and lithium, making them a versatile choice for Mini Cooper owners.
  • NOCO: NOCO battery chargers are highly rated for their compact design and ease of use. Their Genius series features smart charging capabilities and safety features, ensuring your Mini Cooper’s battery is charged efficiently without the risk of overcharging.
  • Schumacher: Schumacher chargers are recognized for their durability and performance. They provide a range of features such as multiple charging modes and built-in safety protections, making them suitable for maintaining and reviving Mini Cooper batteries.
  • Black+Decker: Black+Decker offers reliable battery chargers with user-friendly interfaces. Their chargers typically include smart charging technology and are perfect for both maintenance and emergency situations, ensuring your Mini Cooper stays ready to go.
  • DieHard: DieHard battery chargers are synonymous with reliability and performance. They are designed to charge and maintain batteries effectively, with features such as automatic shut-off and reverse polarity protection, which are essential for safeguarding your Mini Cooper’s battery.

How Do You Choose the Ideal Battery Charger for Your Specific Mini Cooper Model?

Choosing the ideal battery charger for your Mini Cooper involves considering several key factors to ensure compatibility and efficiency.

  • Compatibility with Battery Type: It’s essential to choose a charger that matches the specific battery type of your Mini Cooper, whether it’s a lead-acid, AGM, or lithium-ion battery. Each type has different charging requirements and using the wrong charger can lead to damage or reduced lifespan.
  • Charging Speed: Look for a battery charger that offers multiple charging rates, such as trickle, standard, and fast charging options. Depending on your needs, a faster charger can quickly replenish your battery, while a trickle charger is ideal for maintenance and preventing overcharging.
  • Smart Charging Features: Many modern battery chargers come with smart technology that automatically adjusts the charging rate based on the battery’s state. Features like float mode and temperature compensation help prolong battery life and ensure safety during the charging process.
  • Portability and Design: If you plan to use the charger on the go or in various locations, consider its size and weight. A compact, lightweight design is easier to transport, while a user-friendly interface with clear indicators can simplify the charging process.
  • Safety Features: Prioritize chargers that come with built-in safety features such as short-circuit protection, reverse polarity protection, and overcharge protection. These features help prevent accidents and ensure that your Mini Cooper’s battery is charged safely.
  • Brand Reputation and Reviews: Researching the best battery charger for Mini Cooper involves checking reviews and brand reputation. Established brands with positive feedback often provide reliable products that meet the specific needs of Mini Cooper owners.

What Benefits Can Quality Battery Chargers Provide for Mini Cooper Owners?

Quality battery chargers can offer several advantages for Mini Cooper owners, ensuring optimal performance and longevity of their vehicle’s battery.

  • Extended Battery Life: A high-quality battery charger can help maintain the battery’s health by preventing deep discharges and overcharging, which are detrimental to battery life.
  • Smart Charging Technology: Many of the best battery chargers for Mini Cooper come equipped with smart charging technology that automatically adjusts the charging rate based on the battery’s condition, ensuring efficient and safe charging.
  • Portability: The compact design of quality battery chargers makes them easy to store in the trunk of a Mini Cooper, providing convenience for on-the-go charging and maintenance.
  • Enhanced Safety Features: Quality chargers often include built-in safety features such as reverse polarity protection, short circuit prevention, and thermal protection, which safeguard both the charger and the vehicle’s electrical system.
  • Versatile Compatibility: The best battery chargers can be compatible with various battery types, including lead-acid and AGM batteries, making them a versatile choice for Mini Cooper owners who may have different models or battery setups.
  • Maintenance Mode: Some chargers offer a maintenance or trickle charge mode that keeps the battery topped off during long periods of inactivity, which is especially beneficial for Mini Coopers that are not used frequently.

Extended Battery Life: A high-quality battery charger can help maintain the battery’s health by preventing deep discharges and overcharging, which are detrimental to battery life. Regularly using a quality charger can significantly reduce the risk of battery failure and prolong the lifespan of the battery, ensuring that the Mini Cooper runs smoothly over time.

Smart Charging Technology: Many of the best battery chargers for Mini Cooper come equipped with smart charging technology that automatically adjusts the charging rate based on the battery’s condition, ensuring efficient and safe charging. This technology helps in optimizing charging cycles and can even restore slightly sulfated batteries, making it a wise investment for car owners.

Portability: The compact design of quality battery chargers makes them easy to store in the trunk of a Mini Cooper, providing convenience for on-the-go charging and maintenance. This portability allows Mini Cooper owners to have peace of mind, knowing they can quickly address any battery issues wherever they are.

Enhanced Safety Features: Quality chargers often include built-in safety features such as reverse polarity protection, short circuit prevention, and thermal protection, which safeguard both the charger and the vehicle’s electrical system. These safety measures are crucial for preventing accidents and ensuring the integrity of the battery and car electronics during charging.

Versatile Compatibility: The best battery chargers can be compatible with various battery types, including lead-acid and AGM batteries, making them a versatile choice for Mini Cooper owners who may have different models or battery setups. This compatibility ensures that no matter what type of battery is installed, the charger can handle it effectively.

Maintenance Mode: Some chargers offer a maintenance or trickle charge mode that keeps the battery topped off during long periods of inactivity, which is especially beneficial for Mini Coopers that are not used frequently. This feature helps in preventing battery drain, ensuring that the vehicle is ready to go whenever needed.

How Can Proper Battery Maintenance Extend the Life of Your Mini Cooper’s Battery?

Proper battery maintenance can significantly extend the life of your Mini Cooper’s battery by ensuring it remains in optimal condition and preventing premature failure.

  • Regular Inspection: Frequent checks of your battery can help identify corrosion, loose connections, or signs of wear.
  • Cleaning Terminals: Keeping the battery terminals clean helps maintain a good connection and prevents power loss.
  • Using a Quality Battery Charger: Investing in the best battery charger for Mini Cooper ensures the battery is charged correctly and efficiently.
  • Avoiding Deep Discharges: Minimizing the frequency of deep discharges can prolong battery life, as lithium-based batteries do not respond well to being drained completely.
  • Temperature Management: Extreme temperatures can negatively impact battery performance, so parking in shaded areas or using battery insulation can help.

Regular inspection involves visually checking the battery for any signs of corrosion or damage, which can lead to poor performance. Additionally, it is essential to ensure that the battery is securely mounted, as vibrations can cause internal damage over time.

Cleaning terminals is a simple yet effective maintenance task; using a mixture of baking soda and water can neutralize acid build-up, while a wire brush can help remove corrosion. This maintenance improves electrical connectivity, reducing the risk of starting issues.

Using a quality battery charger specifically designed for Mini Coopers is crucial because it can provide the right voltage and current needed for optimal charging. Features such as automatic shut-off and maintenance modes can help prevent overcharging, which can damage the battery.

Avoiding deep discharges is essential, as many batteries, particularly lead-acid types, can suffer from sulfation if regularly drained too low. Keeping the battery charged above 50% will help maintain its health and longevity.

Temperature management is vital since both extreme heat and cold can adversely affect battery performance. Keeping the battery in a stable temperature environment can improve efficiency and extend its lifespan.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment